Overwatch Director Opens Up About The Gap Between Community and Developers
The Blizzard team has made a lot of effort at being involved in the community, and the team behind Overwatch is no different. With countless posts in their forums on updates about the game, or Game Director Jeff Kaplan addressing the toxicity in the community – the team intends to build a community aspect where the developers are involved and there for the player base. That is why when a recent forum post arose criticizing the size of the the developers and their lack of posts/fixes, the Overwatch director himself took to the defense of his team:
When we launched Overwatch in May of 2016 our team comprised 70 developers. When I say developers, I am specifically talking about artists, engineers, producers, sound/music designers and game designers. We’re now at just north of 100 developers. We do have a few open roles (you can check our job site for these) but we mostly feel pretty good about the size of the team in regards to the things we’d like to accomplish. One of the things we value as a team is the concept of doing more with less. Even though I wouldn’t say we’re necessarily a “small” team as modern development standards go, we’re certainly not an overly large team either.
We view ourselves as artists and craftspeople and we like to avoid that feeling of being “cogs in a large machine”. We like the fact that we own Overwatch together as a unified team with a shared, collective vision. There is not one person — or select people — who dictates what we do. We’re not peons of some visionary — just implementing his or her vision — and we’re certainly not beholden to any corporate “overlords” telling us what we can or cannot do. We are 100+ game developers who absolutely love playing and making Overwatch.
The day we announced/launched/put OW into Beta, the game belonged to a large community. And we truly do see ourselves as the custodians — not overlords — of the game and community. With that said, something that no one can ever take from us is that the 100 or so of us on the team created something together that we truly believe in and stand behind. We have poured our hearts and souls into a game that we believe is special. We’ve staked our names and our careers on it. We try — every waking hour — to show how much love and magic we believe Overwatch can represent.
Since the day we have launched, we’ve only increased our efforts and dedication. Overwatch is a 24/7, 365 days a year affair for us. Overwatch doesn’t stop because it’s 5 o’clock on a Friday evening. Overwatch doesn’t stop because it’s our kids’ birthday.
Do we do everything right? Certainly not. The 100 members of the OW team are *far* more critical than most of you of the game on a good day (although we’re a little more professional about how we express our criticism). You will never meet one of us who says, “the game is perfect”. We have no shortage of ideas of how to make the game better and we are lucky enough to show up to work every day and try to make those things happen.
The developing team definitely has their work cut out for them in a full schedule of fixing bugs and other issues, as well as developing new fresh content for players. Kaplan then goes on to further relate to the player-base the team is there for them and they care about every aspect of the game:
When we launched Overwatch in May of 2016 our team comprised 70 developers. When I say developers, I am specifically talking about artists, engineers, producers, sound/music designers and game designers. We’re now at just north of 100 developers. We do have a few open roles (you can check our job site for these) but we mostly feel pretty good about the size of the team in regards to the things we’d like to accomplish. One of the things we value as a team is the concept of doing more with less. Even though I wouldn’t say we’re necessarily a “small” team as modern development standards go, we’re certainly not an overly large team either.We view ourselves as artists and craftspeople and we like to avoid that feeling of being “cogs in a large machine”. We like the fact that we own Overwatch together as a unified team with a shared, collective vision. There is not one person — or select people — who dictates what we do. We’re not peons of some visionary — just implementing his or her vision — and we’re certainly not beholden to any corporate “overlords” telling us what we can or cannot do. We are 100+ game developers who absolutely love playing and making Overwatch.The day we announced/launched/put OW into Beta, the game belonged to a large community. And we truly do see ourselves as the custodians — not overlords — of the game and community. With that said, something that no one can ever take from us is that the 100 or so of us on the team created something together that we truly believe in and stand behind. We have poured our hearts and souls into a game that we believe is special. We’ve staked our names and our careers on it. We try — every waking hour — to show how much love and magic we believe Overwatch can represent.
Since the day we have launched, we’ve only increased our efforts and dedication. Overwatch is a 24/7, 365 days a year affair for us. Overwatch doesn’t stop because it’s 5 o’clock on a Friday evening. Overwatch doesn’t stop because it’s our kids’ birthday.
Do we do everything right? Certainly not. The 100 members of the OW team are *far* more critical than most of you of the game on a good day (although we’re a little more professional about how we express our criticism). You will never meet one of us who says, “the game is perfect”. We have no shortage of ideas of how to make the game better and we are lucky enough to show up to work every day and try to make those things happen.
We’ve built the team around the people who we consider to be the top developers in the entire industry. And because of that, we view them as amazing, creative individual contributors and not just “mindless implementers” who can be easily multiplied to increase output.
While most players have a few “causes” that they focus on, we – the team – care about *literally* every experience that has anything to do with OW. We care about where a button on the screen goes, what sound it makes, what color it is. We care about what the email says to a player who has just been banned. We care about constantly trying to improve ping times worldwide and server up time. We care about what Mei says when she is sad. We care about the integrity of Top 500 play, the tournament rules for esports, how big the OW logo is on a backpack. We care about all 26 heroes equally.
Each of us wants to be involved and contribute to all of these things plus 10,000 other OW-related things that come up each day. We are the 100 people who created the experience and whether it is good or bad, that’s on us. We know we’re only as good as our last patch.
Our passion and love is for making and playing Overwatch. Things like posting on the forums — for many of us — is not a normal or core part of our job. From Day 1, we felt like we wanted to be a development team that communicated more openly with our player base. We tried to make as many posts on these forums as possible. Our intention — more than anything — was show a presence and let you know that we’re listening. We’re not naive enough to think that we can sufficiently address each player’s concerns here. But we do want you to know that we — the OW development team — are here with you, listening.
We try to do other things to let you know that we’re part of this community as well. We make Developer Update videos so we can talk directly to you and explain what we’re doing and why we’re making decisions. We do not hide behind online handles or layers of Community Managers and PR Spokespeople.
In the final section of the response to the forum post, Kaplan discusses the risks and strains related to having such an open dialogue with their community. While the player base has a strong demand for high communication from the developers, a lot of the team members view it as a risk:
Developers speak to you directly, using our real names. And if you’ll allow me to speak openly for a moment — it’s scary. Overall, the community is awesome to us. But there are some pretty mean people out there. All of our developers are free to post on these forums. Very few of us actually do because it’s extremely intimidating and/or time consuming. It’s very easy to post the wrong thing and make a “promise” to the community that no one intended to make. Once we say we’re working on something, we’re not allowed to “take it back”. It’s set in stone.
Also, because we are open with you and do not hide behind an anonymous handle (like all of you have the luxury of doing), we often times get personally attacked and threatened.
Most great developers I know just love being head’s down making or playing games. The “public speaking/posting” part of the job is downright scary and intimidating. It often feels like there is no winning.
As a result, there are a small few of us who do most of the posting here. Two weeks ago, I was offsite all week without posting access (I cannot make forum posts from my phone for security reasons). The week after that, I came into the office 1 hour later than I normally do (I was feeling extremely fatigued and rather than waking up at 5:40am like I do most days, I woke up at 6:30am). The end result was that for 2 weeks I haven’t posted at my normal rate. I apologize that it’s been a quiet two weeks but that doesn’t mean that we — the OW team — haven’t been working just as hard as we always do and are not dedicated to making this game great.
Just because there are “a lot of threads” or “a lot of upvotes” about a certain topic, does not mean we’re not paying extremely close attention to not only the community feedback — but more importantly — the game itself.
Of course the team talks about Mercy. Of course we talk about Ana. But we talk about all of the heroes. If we post, “we’re talking about Mercy” immediately there is an expectation that she is going to be radically changed in the next patch when the truth is, we might just leave her how she is for a while. We’re not allowed to post that here without our bosses (and I am talking literally here) receiving emails from some of you demanding we be fired. It’s not exactly what I would call a safe environment for creative people to openly express their thoughts and feelings.
Anyway, we always appreciate feedback when it is expressed in an open, direct and constructive way. Player feedback is what has made this game great. We will try to communicate as much as we can. We love being a part of the community and we don’t ever want to view ourselves or be viewed as being separate or removed from that.
Thanks for being patient with us.
The response was met with mixed responses but mostly positive that game director took the time to address their concerns. Of course, there were other responses that shook off Kaplan’s response and asked the team to work harder to address certain concerns. In those responses, you see the truth in Kaplan’s statement about the risks of addressing matters in the forums. The team will likely make no changes to their outreach and will continue to talk directly to the players as they have been doing since launch.
What are your thoughts on the response from Jeff Kaplan regarding the Overwatch team? Do you think they can do more to show what and how they are addressing issues? Sound off with your thoughts about the Overwatch director and more in the comment section below, and don’t forget to check out DFTG on Twitter for gaming and entertainment news live 24/7!
Matt Ruppert715 Posts
Navy Veteran with a penchant for the FPS genre, Chewy has all aspects of the gaming community covered. Don't expect to see him on a console any time soon, however - though he has experience in all platforms, the PC Master Race has a firm hold on him.